Abstract
Contamination of aquatic ecosystems (for example, dams, lakes, rivers, streams) with heavy metals (according to McDonald and Wood (1993), the metals that are of greatest concern in fresh waters are Hg, Pb, Cd, Cu, Zn, AI, Mn and Cr (approximately in order of decreasing toxicity)) has been receiving increased worldwide attention, and the literature has many publications on the topic. These amplified levels of contamination have become a global problem in both developed and developing countries and the impact of them on aquatic environments is severe due to the inability of water to disperse contaminants. To meet this threat, ecotoxicologists face a difficult challenge on how to assess the long-term impacts of metals which have already been released into the environment and which persist in sediment, water and biota. In recent years, the field of biomarker study has evolved and expanded rapidly to address this void. Biomarkers examine molecular and biochemical responses in exposed individuals in an effort to assess the status of an impacted environment and they can also serve as a basis for a Rapid Risk Assessment of Fish Health (RRAFH) employed by water quality managers. This effort to incorporate biomarkers into RRAFH research will eventually be worthwhile. Moreover, with this multidisciplinary approach, cause-effect relationships may be examined.
It was in this context that the present study evaluated three biomarkers (metallothionein (MT), Na+K+ ATPase and heat shock/stress protein 70 (HSP 70)) to determine the integrated physiological responses in Oreochromis mossambicus to one metal (copper (Cu)) at a sub lethal level over the short term (96, 48, 24, 16, 12, 6, 4 and 2 h respectively). The information gained from these tests was valuable in suggesting what the baseline levels of biomarkers in O. mossambicus would be, as studies of metabolic adjustments to stress in fish have been focused on salmonids. The demand for sensitive, specific and rapid biological assays was also addressed by the development of an HSP 70 ELISA. This assay with, with additional refinement, will also prove to be a valuable tool in the management of Cu pollution in this species.
Evaluation of the biomarkers in the gills of O. mossambicus indicated that this species has relatively high levels of MT in their gills compared with other species of fish. Exposure to sub lethal Cu concentrations [Cu] caused fluctuating, but not significant, levels in Na+K+ ATPase and HSP 70 during the exposure time, and the actual [Cu] in the gill seems to be the biggest factor when interpreting results. Significant decreases were found in MT levels in the gill tissue at 2 h and 12 h of exposure. HSP 70 results also indicated non-significant decreases to Cu exposure. Data from the gills analysed in the current study suggest that down-regulation in the biomarker response might be a better indicator of Cu exposure or effect in O. mossambicus. These data also suggest that further studies should rethink the amount of Cu that the fish under investigation would find sub-lethal as this metal seems to be very well regulated in this species of fish and seems frequently to non-significantly effect the chosen biomarkers.
Evaluation of the biomarkers in the liver of O. mossambicus indicated that MT levels present in the liver most likely fall within the in range of normal baselevels for tilapia living in a Cu-rich environment and that HSP 70 in the liver only responds significantly to increased aqueous [Cu] at 16 h of exposure.
This study also confirms current knowledge that the toxicity assessment of any pollutant, including Cu, cannot be exclusively based on one biomarker and that the true value of these biomarkers only becomes evident when they are used not as individual indicators but as integrated responses that influence one another. All these results furnish useful data for future research into the sub lethal effects of a pollutant such as Cu. The next step would be to test the usefulness of these physiological methods for detection of similar responses in natural fish populations inhabiting Cu polluted waters. This will provide a database relating the presence of Cu to biological effects at a molecular level.
Prof. J.H.J. Van Vuuren